2020: Stu Rulnick, Pittsburgh
2019: Conrad Waite, Duquesne
2018: Stu Rulnick, Pittsburgh
2017: Conrad Waite, Duquesne
2016: Stu Rulnick, Pittsburgh
2015: Mike Joseph, Robert Morris
2014: Stu Rulnick, Pittsburgh; Paul Taibi, West Virginia
2013: Christian Wilk, John Carroll
2012: Christian Wilk, John Carroll
2011: Zach Sonnefeld, West Virginia
2010: Bill Waldschmidt, Slippery Rock
2009: Dan Hestin, Indiana U of PA
2008:
2007:
| SEASON | PLAYER OF THE YEAR | ROOKIE OF THE YEAR | COACH OF THE YEAR |
| 2024-25 | Shane Miller, IUP | Cole Bianchin, KSU | Tyler Kutek, WVU |
| 2023-24 | Sean Deakin, JCU | JJ Creighton, KSU | Scott Shantery, JCU |
| 2022-23 | Roman Kraemer, RMU | Shane Miller, IUP | Joe Honzo, IUP |
| 2021-22 | Roman Kraemer, RMU | Sean Deakin, JCU | Stu Rulnick, PITT |
| 2020-21 | --- | --- | --- |
| 2019-20 | Austin Tonkovich, PITT | Olda Virag, PITT | Stu Rulnick, PITT |
| 2018-19 | Nathan Mickey, RMU | Conrad Waite, DUQ | |
| 2017-18 | Jamie Mauro, SRU | Stu Rulnick, PITT | |
| 2016-17 | Sebastian Thomas, WVU | Conrad Waite, DUQ |
